Goodwill reviews

3.2

45% would recommend to a friend

(9,218 total reviews)

Catherine Meloy

48% approve of CEO

38% positive business outlook

Goodwill has an employee rating of 3.2 out of 5 stars, based on 9,218 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The Goodwill employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the ONG y Organizaciones sin fines de lucro industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

9K reviews
1.0
Aug 22, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Can't think of any...nothing comes to mind

Cons

Poor pay no encouragement upper management gives no guidance or direction, simply wait for you to make a mistake so they can attack!

1.0
Aug 19, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

If you're good at managing yourself and taking initiative, this is really a simple cashier/sales associate position; you will get very little direction from the management. You will meet some incredible people who are genuinely good and kind, and these people will make your work enjoyable and memorable, and it will almost force you to forget the terrible customer you had 5 minutes prior. You get to see everything before all of the customers, so you essentially have your first pick at all of the clothing and accessories that pass through the donation center. Most of the time, you'll find a gem - a perfect pair of jeans, a vintage jacket in beautiful condition, costume jewelry from the 1960s, a high-end designer piece that is essentially priceless. The only negative aspect about new merchandise is that employees are barred from purchasing anything new - you have to wait for new merchandise to be out on the floor for 24 hours, because the customers get the first pick. Management is good about schedule flexibility; during my time at Goodwill, I changed my schedule multiple times, and management was always very accommodating.

Cons

As a cashier/sales associate at Goodwill, you will deal with some very lovely people, very rarely. Most of the time, however, you will deal with extremely difficult customers, and when I say extremely difficult customers, I mean it sincerely. The pay is appalling. My ending salary was $8.50, but that's only because the state of New Jersey increased the minimum wage. There is literally no opportunity for advancement or pay increases, and management essentially sees you as expendable. There are monthly bonuses - if the store reaches a certain amount of money by the end of the month - but for a part-time employee working about 40 hours each week, my bonus was never more than $11. Further, you don't qualify for the bonuses unless you've been with the company for 3 months. There is very little direction from the management, and whenever there is any type of mistake, they're always there to breathe down your neck. Security is a huge issue, too: They have cameras everywhere in the store that are operated from Goodwill's HQ in NY, but instead of paying attention to the customers, they focus on watching the employees and making sure that they're doing their work, which is ludicrous, because management should be overseeing the employees, and security should be watching the customers. The store is incredibly messy. Always. A cleaning crew comes in to clean it once every 2 weeks, but it's a fruitless effort, because the store gets completely trashed before the night is over. The store is essentially disorganized - at least this is true for the location where I worked. Everything is Do-It-Yourself, and to be brutally honest, you'd be better off working retail somewhere else - for a company where employees are treated well and where there is the potential for growth.

2.0
Aug 15, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The people at the Corp. office are pretty much the best-smiling, cheerful, they like their jobs. Very good benefits, good PR and presence in the community, good 'spin'. At Corporate, you'll find lots of people willing to help you, if you just ask. (you gotta find the right person to ask, though!) Up until a year and a half ago, I would've rated Goodwill with 5 stars. It was THAT good.

Cons

What comes to mind when you think about working for a non-profit? -That the work for and with the organization would make you feel good, right? -It's because you'd want to feel like you're making a difference, yes? -And since Goodwill is a HUGE name, one would think it'd be AWESOME to work there and you'd be making a difference, right? . That's what I thought & that was my experience when I worked there. Until 2013. * From the date of incorporation of Goodwill Industries of Orange County Ca., 1932 until 2012, it wasn't 'all about the money'. Money coming in of course was important, but our raison d'etre WE were working at Goodwill was everything associated with serving the <mostly> disabled people we called 'clients' who were working, getting trained, getting placed in jobs at the org. That was our Mission, to "provide people with disabilities and other barriers the opportunity to achieve their highest levels of personal and economic independence", & by God we did a GREAT job. They were our clients, WE worked for THEM. It was quality vs quantity and we were a quality org. Every day, you could see the reason. Every single frickin' day. We had a common goal, a common focus, a common need to fill. We got all sorts of caring, 'warm fuzzy' feelings about what we were doing. And it was good. CON: before I was let go, the vision changed; from " "Goodwill of Orange County envisions a world where all individuals with disabilities and other barriers will have the opportunity to participate in a full range of life's experiences, including competitive employment. In support of this vision, we will maintain leadership in creating and providing quality education, training, and employment services to empower individuals to be productive and independent, based on their abilities and interest." to "Over the next five years we intend to double the number of people we serve by providing services that are innovative and driven by the needs of the community." Read those two again. Perhaps it would be clearer to say 'innovative and driven by the needs of the media'. Translation: Quantity vs quality. A revolving door philosophy of 'get 'em in, count 'em, give some service that might help them, then they're outta here.'. CON: The employees organization-wide are now being choked by fear and apprehension. This is partly due to management's obsession with suspicion and mistrust. In the last 2 years, state-of-the art security and video systems have been put in place everywhere except in the bathrooms and IT. NOW, when you talk to someone about anything, you look over your shoulder to see if anyone's around; you talk in an office so the cameras won't see you; you wonder who you can trust (answer: NO ONE). When it gets so bad that an ex-employee who was let go attempts to send an email the next day to their coworkers, management finds out about it, quickly tells IT to block and eliminate those emails, even erasing them off staff emails whether they're opened or not, including any 'sent' emails to that ex-coworker, well, are they that afraid of a stupid goodbye email? Programs are being cut, long-term employees are being fired/let go, the upper management and HR rule by fear. It's not feeling remotely like a non-profit organization should feel. When you open up a can of root beer, you expect root beer and not tap water, yes? When 5 people are let go/position eliminated/reduction in force from the same department right when they walk into work, within 3 business days (one person was let go the day they got back from their honeymoon), that doesn't really seem like something a caring, 'warm fuzzy' organization like Goodwill would do, does it? No, it doesn't. They're gone, to the Goodwill Gulag. Along with appx 30+ people, from January-June 2014.

Viewing 43 - 45 of 9,218 Reviews

Glassdoor has 9,719 Goodwill reviews submitted anonymously by Goodwill employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Goodwill is right for you.