New York Life reviews

3.7

62% would recommend to a friend

(5,473 total reviews)
avatar

Craig DeSanto

76% approve of CEO

62% positive business outlook

New York Life has an employee rating of 3.7 out of 5 stars, based on 5,473 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The New York Life employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Seguros industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

5K reviews
1.0
May 15, 2017
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The training is good. Recruiters see you work for NYL and usually are impressed. Company itself is strong financially. Brand recognition helps on appointments. Support staff was always more helpful than management.

Cons

Management plays the favorites game. I've been on both ends of the spectrum for this. Close a big case and you're the hero for the month. You get all the attention and they talk about you in meetings and use you as the "standard." On the flip side, have a couple slow months and they try to remedy it by constantly policing you on numbers. So on top of the stress of not being able to pay bills and throwing your own money at driving around for appointments, you have managers (who usually used to be agents) breathing down your neck about making a sale. If you ask for help they just talk at you for half an hour and tell you the same schpeel they give you during your first interview. My big question was always, if being an agent is so lucrative why did they all go into management? I'm sure the word "salary" has something to do with it. The commissions are okay, not very competitive with others in the industry. Benefits are astronomical. They charge way too much for "office fees" regardless of how much you actually utilize the home office. The whole structure of managing partners and "teams" is a bunch of malarkey. There is little to no support from other people on your "team." Management uses it to have kum-bay-ah sessions where you say what stressed you out about the week and then your manager just roasts you about it. They try and encourage new agents to work with the established agents, but they usually are just old white men who make you do all the work and take 80% of the commission, without any consequences. I know a personal issue I had was with my licensing, which the admin staff messed up. I ended up having to reapply after having my licenses for two years and had to pay for everything myself with no reimbursement. Because of their mistake. Management pushes product with literally zero shame. If you aren't selling that much life insurance and focus on other areas instead, you'll hear about it constantly. And god forbid if you don't go along with what they tell you. I have been told multiple times that I "should" be doing certain things, with a tone used to imply that it won't look good for me if I didn't comply. Which leads into my next complaint. They tell you from day one that YOU are you're own boss. YOU get to make your schedule. YOU set your hours. But then they hand you a class schedule and set up ridiculous amounts of "admin" time that you're supposed to be at. Without getting paid. At one point I realized that they couldn't do anything if I didn't come to certain things. When you tell me to go out and sell, I'm going to go out and sell. On my own terms. I've been reprimanded for setting appointments on Mondays/Fridays only for them to apologize once they realize I've made a sale. It makes no sense. On multiple occasions on manager would directly contradict another manager on facts and just overall business practice. It comes across as very unprofessional and doesn't help when your questions end up garnering three totally different answers. Also, if you're doing well, they magically don't care if you aren't showing up to anything, even though they preach to "surround yourself with success." So the only people in the office usually are the ones who aren't doing so hot. The biggest red flag that came up was when one manager told me that part of managements business plan is to bring in a bunch of agents with the expectation that a lot won't make it more than a few months, but still have them selling to their close family and friends. So after they leave, those policies go to, guess who? The established agents! Who are already making six figures because they've somehow managed to make it to that point. It's the very definition of a pyramid scheme and I'm actually surprised more people just don't point that out.

3.0
Jan 21, 2009
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Potential to earn income proportional to your effort

Cons

If you are thinking about getting in to selling insurance and/or financial products, it's important to know the nature of this business. Most of the things you read about are for the most part accurate but don't really matter because this industry has a system that been working for many, many years before the last agent arrived. People are talking about the downsides but it's just the nature of the business. You either go with the system or not. You wouldn't get a job as an accountant and then complain that you don't like working with numbers right? It is what it is and we can't really judge it. The company typically will not lie to you and for the most part everything is as it appears. However, there are some things that I wish someone would have shared with me in the beginning though: 1. This job is very hard emotionally and physically. You'll work long hours, spend your own money, and experience more rejection than typically any other time in your life. For men, this is especially hard since we equate what we do with who we are. 2. You really need a fairly significant natural market of friends and relatives. Even if they don't buy from you, at least you’re more likely to get referrals from them which are the lifeblood of your success (now and in the future). If you just moved here or don't know too many people, it will be extremely difficult to find customers. It's not impossible as some people have done it, but it's much, much harder to succeed. Most successful agents started out in their area with plenty of friends, family, and referrals to get them going. Getting past the first year is the biggest hurdle which is why the natural market and/or referrals is so important. Your first year prospecting will most likely be the following years business. In other words, it takes time for new contacts/people to trust you. Of course, I do not have the statistics, but I would estimate based on the number of relatively successful agents at the office, about 8 out of 10 are locals. It's probably the same for other companies. 3. Only about 3 out of 10 make it past the first year for whatever reason 4. Your expenses will be very high so make sure you have a reserve of three to six months to live on. 5. You are not really selling a product in the traditional sense. You are selling based on emotion and your ability to disturb people into action. You have to have this character in the beginning or develop it rather quickly. 6. Don't be shocked when your friends and relatives distance themselves from you. Remember that they think, you think, they are expected to buy something from you. 7. You are a captive agent. Remember this as you can only sell this companies products. Many people want to work with an independent agent who they feel has access to a wider variety of products and services. This may or may not be a problem, but you should be aware of it. There are so many wonderful things about this business and the upside of this career is phenomenal. Just be prepared before you make this decision. I hope this helps.

1.0
May 8, 2009
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Working for a mutual company, being able to try to "milk" that to death in front of clients.

Cons

1. Zero salary - 100% commission. The "PTAS" the recruiting managers spout on & on about only kicks in if you make at least $500 FYC PER MONTH!! If you make $499, you get nothing. For new agents, this can be very demoralizing. 2. Maybe I just wasn't ready for this kind of work (and maybe the next thing I am going to comment on is actually commonplace in the insurance industry) but I have NEVER EVER worked for a company that would actually call people into a room, ask each one of you how much commission you made this week or last, and then tell you about Mr. So & So (who just happens to know millionaires in his natural market) making $40,000 FYC in the last month!!! I find this COMPLETELY demoralizing and does absolutely NOTHING to get me all "rah-rah's" up about my next 3 hour cold-calling session. 3. Personal time? Forget it. The "excellent work-life balance" that the managers who hire you go on and on about is completely bogus. They expect you to work all day and then return to the office each night and cold-call until 8PM until you make the requisite 2 appointments per day. For a new agent with a lousy natural market, this is almost impossible.

Viewing 19 - 21 of 5,473 Reviews

Glassdoor has 6,509 New York Life reviews submitted anonymously by New York Life employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if New York Life is right for you.