New York Life reviews

3.7

62% would recommend to a friend

(5,473 total reviews)
avatar

Craig DeSanto

76% approve of CEO

62% positive business outlook

New York Life has an employee rating of 3.7 out of 5 stars, based on 5,473 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The New York Life employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Seguros industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

5K reviews
3.0
May 20, 2010
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

New York Life is a well-respected, financially sound, established company. It is a great place to work if you are self-motivated, if you work well with people, if you feel rewarded by helping others protect their assets, if you like to learn, and if you want to establish and/or improve your skillset that will translate well into all aspects of business. The company offers a variety of very good heath insurance benefits, including dental and vision coverage. New York Life has been around since the 1800s and it is THE best in the industry. Unlimited income possibilities.

Cons

I am still employed with New York Life and I enjoy my career. The "cons" I am sharing include many small details I wish were told to me at the very start. In summary, be VERY prepared (mentally, financially, physically, and emotionally) to run your own business, from "soup to nuts." Discuss this career with your family and make sure they are supportive; you will need their understanding and flexibility to foster a successful career with New York Life. As with almost all sales positions, your compensation is commission-only based (no base salary or draw), so your success is dependent upon what you produce, period. If you do not have adequate savings to support daily living and business expenses for at least 3 months, this may not be the career to choose. Additionally, as others have mentioned, there are a number of details about being an agent at New York Life that are never disclosed to you or glossed over when reviewing your employment contract. And most importantly, the company changes the “rules of the game constantly,” especially with regard to overall compensation. (A) Agent = SALES position. There are good and bad aspects of being commission-based. Yes, it is true "skies are the limit;" however, take that with a grain of salt. The most difficult part of compensation at New York Life is the complexity involved in understanding the pay ledger and how you actually get paid. The majority of partners (managers) cannot even explain compensation! Be financially prepared for months you will not get paid because it WILL happen. If a client gets denied insurance or they cancel their policy, commission is reversed. You will either need to sell more products to off-set the reversal -or- pay the money back directly to the company. The operations/payroll department is very slow when processing policy cancellations, so you may get a reversal of commissions for an event that happened many months prior. This is important to realize so you are not caught off-guard! (B) As an agent, you must pay for all overhead expenses and as a new full-time agent, you are required to rent an office space from the company. You have to pay for things like your own computer/laptop, internet service, cel phone, copies...if there is an expense attached, you are responsible for it. (C) Management has high-sales expectations, but they do not foster a balanced, conducive environment to "produce" during your first years with the company. As a new, full-time agent, you will be required to attend quite a large number of training classes and meetings. On one hand, it is fantastic the company offers so much training, but it does not leave much time for appointments and drumming up new business. This is a "sales" position, so working long days and weekends should be expected. You will also be pressured by management to solicit business (and referrals) from your own family, friends, and community. Unfortunately, this is almost essential to make it your first year with the company. (D) You are expected to manage, find, or purchase your own leads and determine how to get new clients/business on your own. Management will encourage you to join networking groups and participate in events, but realize you are responsible for all fees associated with doing so. (E) A manager/partner is still SALES with compensation like a pyramid organization. You will see some people get promoted to management who have no leadership or coaching skills as well as those who are great motivators - this happens at most any company. Partners (and above) are still selling the company and recruiting for more agents, as a partner’s income is based upon their agents’ (team) sales. (F) Your employment contract is finite. After 2 years, your commission percentage on new business goes down - no surprise there. You have the option to open your own office (either physically located at your GO -or- physically located off-site). Again, you have to pay for everything either way. (G) If you decide to ever leave the company, understand that you may not be absent from reversal of commissions for quite some time. Again, this is one of those small details that are glossed over and could have big financial impacts to your future after New York Life. If one of your clients cannot pay an insurance premium -or- if they cancel a policy altogether, you receive a bill from New York Life telling you to re-pay the commissions. I do not know if this is even legal, but if you do not pay the “bill,” they will send you to collections.

5.0
Jan 12, 2017

Agent

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The opportunity is limitless regarding moving up the ladder. If you want to go from agent to managing partner, there's a clear cut path to follow. There's no cap on what you make as an agent, which is my favorite part. What you work for - you earn! The Development Managers, Trainers, and Partners at New York Life go above and beyond to help the agents succeed. You just have to put in the effort! It's a commission-only business, so if you don't work, you don't get paid!

Cons

You're on your own to grow your business. You find your own market(s), generate your own leads, and work with what you have (or don't have) to make it as an agent. It's tough coming from only having worked the standard 9-5 job, and any real residual is recognized after a full year. No sales, no money. There's no salary and training allowance is paid upon sale of products years 1-3 after hire.

4.0
Oct 6, 2017

Sales Agent Review

Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

This is a position where you get what you put in - period! This is not a job, but a business. If you see this as a job, then you will not be upset when you have to come out of pocket to pay for things to help you grow your business. I have been with the company now for a year. If you listen to the management team and follow the training program, you can be successful. There is a networking system that you will learn - follow it. The company offers university type training, benefits like group health, dental, vision, and 401K, and management support. In the first year, you get a lot of bonuses to help you build your business. But you must first write a certain amount of business each month to get the extra bonus money. If you do, it helps you survive when money gets low and bills need to be paid. You can get several awards that you must get in your first year. I find that the people who do not hit the ground running, tend to fail. Stay consistent, win awards, and study to find success. This is a great company to build a career but it will not be an easy journey. Find great mentors and stay positive. Do not do this business just to make money because you will fail. I love the industry and I know no matter where I go, putting in the hard work the first 3 to 5 years is crucial. So, because NYL has great products, name recognition, and is a mutual company, I have an advantage.

Cons

New York life can do a better job at being transparent in the interview stage of the process. They show you the perks, but do not share that it can be tough if you don't have a savings or significant other to help you financially when you hit rough patches. They don't share all the fees they charge you to work for them life desk, portal, ect.They don't tell you that you lose some important bonuses your second year. They don't tell you your contractual requirements during the interview, only after. They don't talk about reversals and how that can hurt your business. They don't tell quick they will let you go at the end of the year if you did not meet your contractual requirements. Also, depending on the office you work out of, there can be too many meetings that take you away from sales, which is never good.

Viewing 4 - 6 of 5,473 Reviews

Glassdoor has 6,509 New York Life reviews submitted anonymously by New York Life employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if New York Life is right for you.