CarSense and the auto sales industry not for me - Sales CarShop Employee Review

2.0
Apr 3, 2015
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

You get to work with some truly quality used automobiles. I was strictly a new car person until I started working at CarSense. You can feel good about what you are offering.

Cons

I've looked over many reviews of CarSense, and I'm hoping job seekers are intelligent enough to know that any business, especially a car dealership, couldn't possibly be as perfect as many of these reviews make it out to be. I'll start with some of the remarks on training : training consists of sitting at your desk your first day watching multiple pre recorded videos. I was originally told I would have a mentor, and that never occurred. I recently had my three month review and the member of management that gave it to me even remarked I didn't have one. You spend two full 8 hour work days with an outside trainer teaching you about the Allstate aftermarket products you sell. And then you have a one day training with one of the VP'S who is also titled as HR/cultural development. To hear people brag about his training, you would think you were about to listen to some prophet, when it ended up being nothing but common sense and a review of all the recorded videos you watch. CarSense prides itself in being non traditional in regards to car dealerships. Although I've never worked at a traditional dealership, I've interviewed with plenty and have worked with those who have. One thing that was initially attractive to me was the schedule. It sounds great, but make no mistake about it, traditional or non traditional dealership, the car industry is the car industry. Being scheduled certain hours are one thing, what you end up working is totally another. CarSense uses an "up" system, meaning you sign a list every day depending on when you get to work. The first person "up" gets to greet the first walk in customer, the second person mans the phones. Sounds fair, right? In a perfect world, sure, but it's not supervised and the rules change depending on who is there each day. It actually ends up being more of a hindrance than anything. I was scolded by a long time employee once because I answered the phone and it wasn't my turn to answer it, at least in his eyes. The non sense and immaturity that it breeds isn't worth it. I'm all for a traditional dealership on this sense, where one central person answers the phone and it's every man or woman for themselves. You are expected to cover CarSense philosophy with every customer you encounter. Doesn't matter if you already spoke with them over the phone and bored them to death with it, and if you don't, be prepared to be scolded. Many people who have questioned me about CarSense, including customers, want to know about "non commission sales people". Many people associate being non commission with it not being important to sell a car. Not the situation at all: you are not paid on the traditional commission structure, but you are paid on a volume bonus, and this is how you make the bulk of your income. You may be told during an interview that you can make $60000 or more a year. To do so, you need to focus on selling at least 20 cars or more a month. Which means handling 2 to 3 customers at a time, and can mean throwing that wonderful sounding schedule out the door. Prepare to deal with fellow employees who claim the customer you greeted is actually theirs, even though they didn't ask for them, and haven't spoke to them in months. I'm sure this is something you encounter in all car sales, but beware if it's your first time. There truly is no negotiating in the price of the car. When it comes to the price of the customers trade in, or what percentage rate the customer is looking for for financing, you are told the same thing, but you are also asked if a customer has a number in mind when talking about a trade, and financing begs and pleads with you to get the customer to finance through CarSense if they indicate they have their own financing or if they are paying cash. If the customer still decides to pay cash or deal with their own financing, don't be surprised if you witness a temper tantrum from the finance manager. There is also supposed to be no negotiating when it comes to finance or trade ins, but if a deal doesn't work out, you're asked if the customer had specific numbers in mind, which always left me wondering what it mattered if CarSense final numbers are what they are. It's beneficial for you to master selling the Allstate aftermarket coverages. It will benefit you financially and may eliminate you seeing the finance manager throw another tantrum. Keep in mind, you will be working in a large, open air building, where everything you say can be heard. If you don't sell a car to an opportunity, be prepared to be interrogated as to why. CarSense prides itself on being a faith based company, even going so far as to put bibles in every car they sell. The behavior I experienced from management on down was, at times, far from God like. I'm not one of those new age sickening politically correct types, but it is the 21st century, and some behaviors in the work place should be gone for good. I gave car sales a try, I had three offers made to me all at the same time and felt CarSense was the best choice. I'm thrilled to be out of the industry and just as happy to be away from CarSense

avatar
CarShop Response
11y
Thank you for your honest feedback. While no one likes to receive negative feedback, everyone, including CarSense can learn from constructive criticism. We will certainly take a look at all the items you mentioned in your review, but for now, I’d like to touch on a few of the areas. First, you are correct that you were never assigned a mentor. We simply dropped the ball. This was inexcusable and we will be sure correct this for all new Sales Consultants going forward. Regarding the culture of CarSense, it is something we totally believe in; therefore, we put a tremendous amount of emphasis on it. We are proud of the way our customers and associates are treated and want to convey that to our customers at every opportunity. You mentioned that management wants to know when a deal doesn’t work out if a customer had specific numbers in mind. CarSense realizes that there is as much to learn about car sales from both our buying customers as well as those that decide not to purchase from us. We listen to all the people who enter our doors – whether they buy or not. You’re right on target that we ask our sales consultants to be informed on our aftermarket offerings. That is why, during your training phase, that a full day is dedicated to this topic. After all, we can’t expect you to be a master at a product that we didn’t properly train you on. I’m sorry your time at CarSense was so short. I believe that over time you would have come to see that the CarSense way of working, including our Philosophy, makes for a rewarding work environment. Like my brother Scott once told me, it's not how you start the race , its how you finish that counts. We wish you nothing but the best in your future endeavors.

Explore other reviews about CarShop

5.0
Mar 30, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

After completing my first full quarter with CarShop, I can confidently say this has exceeded my expectations on every level. What initially stood out during the hiring process was the level of transparency—clear communication around expectations, performance metrics, and growth opportunities. That honesty has proven to be consistent with the day-to-day reality of the organization. From an operational and cultural standpoint, CarShop demonstrates a strong commitment to both its people and its customers. The caliber of talent across the organization is impressive—experienced, collaborative professionals who take ownership of their work while supporting one another. There is a clear alignment between leadership messaging and execution, which builds trust and drives performance. Having worked in roles spanning operations, marketing, logistics, and management, I place a high value on consistency between what is promised and what is delivered. CarShop delivers on that alignment. The work environment is structured yet supportive, with a focus on accountability, continuous improvement, and results. Overall, I’m extremely satisfied with my role, my colleagues, and the broader organization. It’s rare to find a company where the hiring experience accurately reflects the culture and expectations you step into—but CarShop does exactly that and I couldn't be happier professionally.

Cons

My commute is about an hour each way and there is no hybrid option - working from my home office 2 days per week for instance. Overall this is a small "Con" compared to the amazing "Pros" of my position at CarShop.

avatar
CarShop Response
1mo
WOW! Thank you very much for this terrific review. Your perspective as a recent addition to the team is really important. We believe the onboarding process goes a long way towards instilling confidence that you made the right choice to join our team. As you mentioned, it also gives us the chance to show that our commitment to culture and treating each other well is real! Thank you for being an important part of our team!
3.0
Jan 27, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

The culture in this location is great. I’ve never worked anywhere where the people (on multiple departments) got along so well and don’t make you hate going to work. Very little cliquey behavior. If you make the effort to get to know the other departments, you’ll have an easier time.

Cons

The competition is on the lower side of the industry. In sales, you have to be available even on your days off leaving a less than desirable work life balance. The expectations for the Mount holly location are the same as the stores that see a larger volume of customers. Some days you will just be sitting there. Your base salary is like $10 an hour, and the only way to get paid more is getting up in tiers which is super easy at the 5 other locations, but you’ll mostly be in the lower tier at Mount holly. Not because you don’t do your job but because there simply isn’t always enough leads. Then there’s the fact that you get blamed when something mechanical goes wrong or there’s a spot missed during detail. Car swaps can be a double edge sword. If you want to get your foot in the door in cartels it’s a great place to start. Also they will expect you to clear snow during storms.

avatar
CarShop Response
3mo
Thank you for your thorough review. The CarShop culture is the foundation for everything we do, so we're glad that it resonated with you as well while you were on the team. The sales profession does require some flexibility in schedule, but our teams are pretty great about working together to help make it happen. We actually see tremendous opportunity in Mount Holly these days! Leads are flowing and the team is taking advantage of the generous pay plan/tiers. Ironically, mutual accountability and fairness/equity are two of our core values. Thanks for voicing a concern. We'll speak with the team to understand more. Best of luck to you!
See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All