Secret Shop CSE scores aka foolishness - Product Consultant Sephora Employee Review

3.0
Mar 6, 2010
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

- Nice coworkers (Depending on location of course) - In most if not all Illinois locations the pay starts out at least $2.00 more than minimum wage. - One can receive paid time off( even though it takes about a year). - Discounts on products, gratis(free beauty products each month), and free samples. - An opportunity to be educated on various brands, learn techniques for makeup and skincare.

Cons

-SECRET SHOPS!!!!!!! CSE customer service evaluations at least 4 per month at the Sephora Inside JCPenney location I work at, I believe locations outside of JCPenney receive surveys instead. The CSE scores are taken way too seriously, even though they are just suppose to be learning/training tools. They store wants you to remember and perfom at least 20 different things for the customer as well as show them around the whole store. This means every customer that comes in, we have to constantly bug and check up on, and this actually annoys many customers, it doesn't help them. If a consultant receives a CSE score of less than 86 out of 101 or 85% they have to be put through embarassment by having it showed around to each coworker with comments written on it by the management as well as have their job is threatened by a stupid questionarre filled out by a stranger that is not trained to be a professional secret shopper.A completely unfair/unneccesary evaluation. - The management does not like giving time off if it is inconvenient for them or clashes with time that they want off. - Sephora Inside JCPenney locations don't redeem the birthday emails, or give out Sephora brand gift cards, only JCPenney location gift cards, and the store carries far less brands than an outside location. This pisses some customers off.

Explore other reviews about Sephora

5.0
Jun 2, 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Support, Benefits, Growth, Community, & Skillfulness

Cons

Pay, Customers, Hours, Uniforms, & Management at times

3.0
Mar 18, 2026
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Loved learning more about products and working with most of the other team members. Helping people find products that worked for them was really fun.

Cons

Managers are WEIRD. They play favorites and will talk about it while you are standing right there. Practically make you beg for hours. If you are anything other than the current viral makeup style look, you will get less opportunities. Leadership acts like mean high school girls. Working here took away a lot of my passion for the beauty industry for a long time. Also, when it comes to gratis - why are you letting certain managers walk out with 4 bags of things that they have hand picked? Then leaving whatever they discarded to be handed out??? Constantly had missing gratis from my bag because of managers going through the products they wanted. Scheduling is not flexible or even makes sense. Whoever they like gets better shifts. Would constantly have extra shifts added with no notice until an hour before the shift. Or shifts taken away because a favorite wanted them.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All